gb fr
For a Lady Pope

The biblical basis for the doctrine on contraception

There are no verses in the Old Testament, and even less in the New Testament, that explicitly condemn contraception. The only reference made then was to the term withdrawal or, in other words, coitus interruptus and God know that the Old Testament contains numerous verses on everything forbidden or obligatory.

However the Catholic Church has built all its doctrine around one passage only, a passage taken from Genesis in the Old Testament.

Lets carefully reread the text in order to verify the legitimacy of the Popes’ interpretation.

Amongst the obligations laid out in Jewish law is the one asking a man to ensure that his brother, who has died without leaving any descendants, has a child, and this is to be achieved through him having sexual relations with his sister-in-law. It is, in some ways, an obligation, albeit a very restrictive one, to commit adultery. An illustration of this duty can be found in Genesis (ch.38) in the story of Onan, whose brother died without having a child. Although he was ready to honour his sister-in-law, he was not prepared to respect the law of levirate (brother-in-law in Hebrew). In Verse 9 it is written; “And Onan knew that the seed should not be his; and it came to pass, when he went in unto his brother's wife, that he spilled it on the ground, lest that he should give seed to his brother.” He was then slain by God who was angered by his attitude. God killed Onan because he hadn’t respected the levirate law.

It is because of these verses that the Church forbade coitus interruptus. This crime was seen as worse than the crime of homicide - God killed Onan, but he didn’t kill Cain when he murdered his brother Abel. This punishment has struck peoples’ imagination.

The Church has based its philosophy on this one individual case, declaring that all forms of contraception are forbidden. The Onan text is the only one in the bible that refers to any type of contraception and it has been ridiculously exploited.

The problem is in understanding why God condemned Onan. God reproached Onan for not wanting to give his sister-in-law any descendants. Onan refused to respect the levirate law (Dt 25, 5-6).

There were only two ways in which Onan could have behaved according to his beliefs. He could either have refused to sleep with his sister-in-law under different pretexts or he had to use contraception, the only one at his disposal being to withdraw before ejaculation.

God would have condemned Onan to death either way – either for practising coitus interruptus or for refusing to have sexual relations with his sister-in-law, otherwise known as continence. The conclusion that the Church has come to is that withdrawal before ejaculation and continence are both condemned by God.

The logic that says that Onan wasn’t condemned because he refused to give his sister-in-law any offspring, but because of the way he refused to do it is absurd. In other words, it is obvious that it is not the method used that God disapproved of, but the intention to disobey the levirate law.

For twenty centuries, through its fear of sex, the Church has not been able to distinguish the fact that Onan’s punishment was because of his refusal to respect the levirate law and not because of the fact that he used contraception. All Catholic conjugal sexuality is thus based upon a sophism, which is frightening to say the least.

Other articles

Is Christianity a religion of peace?

In a world where physical or moral violence is common and where religions are pointing the finger, we are entitled to ask whether Christianity is a source of peace or of savagery.

2014 Synod on the Family

Many of the faithful wonder if the Church is ready to change its pastoral activities and therefore its doctrine on the family. The expected points of debate were essentially the Church’s position on the banning of contraception, the fate of the divorced who later remarry, the practice of in-vitro fertilization, couples living together outside marriage, homosexuality ...

Is the church able to adapt to the ideas of its time

When looking at the history of the Church over the past two centuries, everyone is entitled to ask him or herself whether or not the Church can cope with the changes in attitudes and whether or not it can at least go some way to changing or developing its doctrine.

Pope Francis speaks of women

The Church, rather than being a beacon in the field of women's rights, has extinguished the light. Let’s hope that Pope Francis can reverse the trend and embrace many female collaborators

The true reasons for prohibiting the ordination of women

Is it really acceptable that what caused the separation of women from worship at the time of Jesus Christ - periodic impurity - can still have an influence in today’s 21st century? The fact that the Catholic Church continues to uphold such a thesis is quite simply unbelievable.

The nuns rebellion

The nuns are rebelling and it will hurt. Nothing is more rebellious than a woman. They are determined to have the right to speak. How far will it go?

A hundred days of Pope Francis

After one hundred days, we should have an idea of his main principles, even more so because, at his age, we can imagine that his philosophy, if not to say his religion, is deeply founded and therefore he knows exactly in what direction he wants to go

. What the majority of Catholics expect from Pope Francis

What they want to see is developments throughout the whole Church.

Aids and immanent justice (poetic justice)

Archibischop of Belgium (machelen-Brussels) compares the disaese to the environmental disasters caused by humans. "When you mistreat the environment, it finally ends up by mistreating you. And when you mistreat human love, it might just look for revenge,” he said.

Paedophilia within the Belgian Catholic Church

Summarising the evolution of the cases of paedophilia in the Belgian Catholic Church is not easy, as so many events have taken place over the past few years. We will therefore simply underline the main events. The most complete history of events can be found in the parliamentary committee’s report, http://www.lachambre.be/FLWB/PDF/53/0520/53K0520002.pdf, which treated the subject. We have drawn heavily on this resource. Various commissions are often referred to when talking about paedophilia within the Belgian Catholic Church. There were two internal commissions that were set up by the Church, one following the other. The first was the Halberghe Commission (2000 - February 2009) and the second, the Adriaenssens Commission (March – June 2010). Furthermore, the Parliamentary Commission, referred to above, worked from October 28th 2010 to March 31st 2011.

Comments

You must be logged in to leave a reply. Login »